Gary Carter Paintings & Artwork for Sale | Gary Carter Art Value Price Guide

Sep. 05, 2026
Gary Carter Signed Limited Edition Print
Est: -
Title: “When starvation is a flinch away”. Signed and numbered 486/1000 on the lower right corner. Includes a coa. In good condition. Overall measures approximately 22in x 31in. Nb17415 Eds
EJ'S Auction & Appraisal
Jul. 29, 2026
Gary Carter (b. 1939), "In Her Chair"
Est: $800 - $1,200
Gary Carter (b. 1939) "In Her Chair" Oil on panel Signed lower left: G. Carter; signed again, titled, and inscribed "759," verso
John Moran Auctioneers
May. 15, 2026
Gary Carter (American, B. 1939) Lithograph on Wove Paper 'Big Rings Dance', H 17.5" W 32"
Est: $200 - $400
Numbered 83/85, pencil signed lower right. Framed. Provenance: Donald Polin, Okemos, MI. By descent to his daughter. Dimensions: H 17.5" W 32"
DuMouchelles
Apr. 18, 2026
Gary Carter Daisy Pass
Est: $500 - $1,000
Gary Carter (American, 1939-2005) Daisy Pass Oil stick and pencil on paper 22 x 34.25 (in) 35 x 49.75 x 1.5 (in) framed Signed Gary Carter CA, lower right $500 - $1,000 Lot includes a Certificate of Authentication issued by Claggett / Rey Gallery.
Larsen Art Auction
Jan. 24, 2026
Gary Carter (19392025) Original Cowboy Study
Est: $2,500 - $5,000
Featured in this lot is this original large study drawing of a cowboy branding pen by Gary Carter born in 1939 and died in 2025. The sketch features a wonderfully and professionally crafted graphite sketch construction that shows a branding pen with cowboys attending the steers needing cut with their back up horses tied to the fence while they are working. The artist signature is in the bottom right hand corner with his artist hallmark shown next to the signature. Gary Carter (19392025) was an American Western artist known for his authentic and humorous paintings of cowboy life, wildlife, and landscapes of the American West. He gained valuable insight into cowboy life during his time as a resident artist at Sun Ranch in Montana. A member and past president of the Cowboy Artists of America (CAA), Carter was also adopted into the Crow Nation in 1991, taking the name "Eagle Man". His work is characterized by strong narratives and a deep appreciation for the history and spirit of the West. The condition of this framed sketch is well preserved with no obvious signs of damage and shows a well preserved overall condition. The measurements of this framed sketch is 19" x 27" and the visible artwork measures 10 1/4" x 18 1/4". The collective weight of this framed artwork is 7lb 4oz.
North American Auction Company
Nov. 22, 2025
Gary Carter "No Seconds Chance" Signed & Numbered Print
Est: -
Signed And Numbered 68/85 On The Lower Right Corner. Title: "no Seconds Chance". Includes Coa On The Reverse. In Used Condition With Slight Wear To The Frame. Frame Measure Approximately 23.25in X 40.5in; Image Measures Approximately 17in X 34in. Nr8797 Eds
EJ'S Auction & Appraisal
Nov. 22, 2025
Gary Carter "Barons Of Beef" Signed & Numbered Print
Est: -
Signed And Numbered 603/850 On The Lower Right Corner. Title: "barons Of Beef". Includes Coa On The Reverse. In Used Condition With Slight Wear To The Frame. Frame Measure Approximately 27in X 39.5in; Image Measures Approximately 19in X 31in. Nr8797 Eds
EJ'S Auction & Appraisal
Nov. 22, 2025
Gary Carter "Aux Ailments Du Pays" Print On Paper
Est: -
Signed And Numbered 533/850 On The Lower Right Corner. Title: "aux Ailments Du Pays". Includes Coa. In Used Condition With Slight Wear To The Frame. Frame Measure Approximately 27.5in X 39in; Image Measures Approximately 19.5in X 31in. Nr8797 Eds
EJ'S Auction & Appraisal
Nov. 22, 2025
Gary Carter Signed & Numbered Framed Print
Est: -
Signed And Numbered 483/850 On The Lower Right Corner. Title: "in The Eight Month Of Winter". Includes Coa. In Used Condition With Slight Wear To The Frame. Frame Measure Approximately 25in X 42in; Image Measures Approximately 17in X 34in. Nr8797 Eds
EJ'S Auction & Appraisal
Nov. 07, 2025
Gary Carter Triptych Print Set
Est: $50 - $75
10 1/2" by 28 1/2" framed.
Davis Brothers Auction
Nov. 07, 2025
Gary Carter Triptych Print Set
Est: $50 - $75
9 1/2" by 27 1/2" framed.
Davis Brothers Auction
Aug. 26, 2025
Gary Carter (b. 1939), "Iron Backside (Custer)," 1971
Est: $5,000 - $7,000
Gary Carter (b. 1939) "Iron Backside (Custer)," 1971 Oil on Masonite Signed and with the artist's device lower right: Gary Carter, inscribed "1876" as part of the composition; signed again, titled, dated, and with the artist's copyright, all verso: 1971
John Moran Auctioneers
Aug. 16, 2025
Gary Carter Rocky Mountain Top Signed Print
Est: -
In Used Condition With Slight Wear Present. Numbered 417/850. Signed On The Lower Right Hand Corner. Frame Measuring Approximately 28 By 41 Inches. Image Measuring Approximately 17.5 By 31 Inches. Bh14822 Ja
EJ'S Auction & Appraisal
Jun. 14, 2025
Gary Carter Five Minute Furlough Print
Est: $75 - $125
Signed and Numbered. 29" by 40" framed.
Davis Brothers Auction
May. 02, 2025
Gary Carter Bachelor Quarters Print
Est: $75 - $125
Signed and Numbered. 29" by 45 1/2" framed.
Davis Brothers Auction
May. 02, 2025
Gary Carter Virginia City Stage Print
Est: $100 - $150
Signed and numbered. 32 1/2" by 22" framed.
Davis Brothers Auction
Apr. 12, 2025
Gary Carter Montana Oil on Board Painting
Est: $2,000 - $3,000
Title is Elk Camp at Hillgard. 16" by 20" unframed. 22 3/4" by 26 3/4" framed. Provenance: Private Montana Collection, Davis Brothers Auction, Altermann Galleries, Scottsdale Art Auction, Jamison Galleries West. Gary Carter (Born 1939) is active/lives in Montana, Arizona. Gary Carter is known for Western frontier genre and landscape painting. Born in Hutchinson, Kansas, Gary Carter is a realist painter and sculptor of the contemporary and historic American West including cowboy's, mountain men, Indians and the landscape where they live or lived. Many of his childhood trips were with his father backpacking in the Sierra Mountains of California. He served in the Army, and then earned a BFA degree with honors from the Art Center College of Design* in Los Angeles. He had moved to California with his family when his father took a job with Walt Disney productions. From 1971-1972, he was the in-house illustrator for a California design studio, but a sell-out show in 1973 of his own art persuaded him to become a full-time painter. In 1978, he won Best of Show at a Montana Historical Society exhibition. He paints the landscape and wild animals of a remote area of Montana where he lives with his wife, Marlys, near the West Entrance of Yellowstone Park. His former bunkhouse studio, where he acquired much insight into the life of the cowboy, is several miles from his home at Sun Ranch. In 1982, Gary Carter was elected to membership of the Cowboy Artists of America*, and in 1986, served as President. In CAA annual exhibitions, he received a Gold award for Drawing and Other Media in 1990 and 1997. In 1991, he was adopted by the Crow Tribe and the Real Bird Family, and, made a member of the Big Lodge Clan, given an Indian name of "Eagle Man." This adoption occurred at a Pow-Wow on the Crow reservation at Medicine Tail Coulee near Hardin, Montana, at a redesignation of the Little Horn Battlefield.
Davis Brothers Auction
Apr. 10, 2025
Gary Carter Signed Framed Photo, Steiner Authenticated
Est: $10 - $200
This framed photograph captures Hall of Fame catcher Gary Carter in action during his time with the New York Mets. Personally signed by Carter in ink, this piece includes a Steiner Sports holographic authentication sticker, ensuring its authenticity. A key player in the Mets' 1986 World Series championship, Carter remains one of the most beloved figures in franchise history. Professionally framed and matted, this collectible display measures 22"L x 26"H and is perfect for Mets fans and baseball memorabilia collectors alike. Dimensions: See Description
Lion and Unicorn
Nov. 12, 2024
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) Signed, Sealed & Delivered, 1989
Est: $4,000 - $6,000
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) Signed, Sealed & Delivered, 1989 oil on canvas signed Gary Carter and dated (lower left); signed, titled, and dated (verso) 20 x 40 inches Property from the Collection of a Missouri Company
Freeman’s | Hindman
Nov. 12, 2024
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) Paradise In Colter's Hell - Midway Geyser Basin, Yellowstone National Park, 1990
Est: $5,000 - $8,000
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) Paradise In Colter's Hell - Midway Geyser Basin, Yellowstone National Park, 1990 oil on canvas signed Gary Carter and dated (lower left); signed, titled, and dated (verso) 24 x 40 inches This lot is located in Denver. Property from the Collection of a Missouri Company
Freeman’s
Nov. 12, 2024
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) High Card for Kansas City, 1988
Est: $5,000 - $7,000
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) High Card for Kansas City, 1988 oil on canvas signed Gary Carter and dated (lower right); signed, titled, and dated (verso) 18 x 36 inches This lot is located in Denver. Property from the Collection of a Missouri Company
Freeman’s | Hindman
Nov. 12, 2024
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) Crow Fair, 1991
Est: $8,000 - $12,000
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) Crow Fair, 1991 oil on canvas signed Gary Carter and dated (lower right); signed, titled, dated, and annotated (verso) 40 x 60 inches This lot is located in Denver. Property from the Collection of a Missouri Company
Freeman’s | Hindman
Nov. 12, 2024
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) The Curly Wolves, 1990
Est: $5,000 - $8,000
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939) The Curly Wolves, 1990 oil on canvas signed Gary Carter and dated (lower left); signed, titled, and dated (verso) 24 x 40 inches This lot is located in Denver. Property from the Collection of a Missouri Company
Freeman’s
Sep. 27, 2024
Gary Carter Framed Print Five Minute Furlough
Est: $25 - $50
12 1/2" by 10 1/4".
Davis Brothers Auction
Sep. 17, 2024
Gary Carter "Sacajawea's Reunion" Oil Painting
Est: $4,000 - $8,000
Gary Carter (American, b. 1939). Oil on canvas over masonite titled "Sacajawea's Reunion" depicting the titular figure as she approaches a group of the Shoshone tribe on August 17, 1805. Signed along the lower right.
Revere Auctions
Sep. 06, 2024
Gary Carter Big Riding Dance Limited Print
Est: $100 - $150
43" by 29" framed. Signed and numbered.
Davis Brothers Auction
Sep. 06, 2024
Gary Carter Five Minute Furlough Limited Print
Est: $75 - $125
35 3/4" by 24". Signed and numbered.
Davis Brothers Auction
Sep. 06, 2024
Gary Carter In The Yellowstone Print
Est: $100 - $150
35" by 24". Signed and numbered.
Davis Brothers Auction
Sep. 06, 2024
Gary Carter Elk Lake Divide Print
Est: $75 - $125
24" by 36". Signed and numbered.
Davis Brothers Auction
Sep. 06, 2024
Gary Carter Rough N Ready Outfitters Print
Est: $50 - $75
36" by 24". Signed and numbered.
Davis Brothers Auction
Sep. 06, 2024
Gary Carter Paradise In Colter's Hell Print
Est: $75 - $125
36" by 23". Signed and numbered.
Davis Brothers Auction
Sep. 06, 2024
Gary Carter Firehole Basin Print
Est: $100 - $150
23 1/4" by 36". Signed and numbered.
Davis Brothers Auction
Aug. 03, 2024
Gary Carter, "Hill Gard Molly"
Est: $2,500 - $4,500
Gary Carter (b. 1939), "Hill Gard Molly", Oil on canvas, Signed and dated 73 lower middle Titled verso
Scottsdale Art Auction, LLC
Aug. 03, 2024
Gary Carter, "I'd Hire You but I'm Short Handed"
Est: $3,000 - $4,000
Gary Carter (b. 1939), "I'd Hire You but I'm Short Handed", Oil on canvas, Signed/CA and dated 04 lower right
Scottsdale Art Auction, LLC
Jun. 08, 2024
Gary Carter B Troop vs The Dust Cutters Print
Est: $50 - $75
Signed and Numbered. 14 1/2" by 20".
Davis Brothers Auction
Jun. 08, 2024
Gary Carter Red Dog Saloon Print
Est: $75 - $125
20" by 36". Signed and numbered.
Davis Brothers Auction
Jun. 08, 2024
Gary Carter Come n' Git It Print
Est: $75 - $125
Signed and Numbered. 23" by 36".
Davis Brothers Auction
Jun. 08, 2024
Gary Carter Red Dog Saloon Print
Est: $75 - $125
Signed and Numbered. 20" by 36".
Davis Brothers Auction
May. 06, 2024
Gary Carter Rookie Card
Est: -
Gary Carter Rookie Card
Lark Mountain Auction Company
Apr. 13, 2024
Gary Carter Montana Cowboy Oil Painting
Est: $2,000 - $3,000
Title is Wolf Creek Camp. 8" by 14" unframed. 16 1/4" by 22 1/4" framed. Oil on Board. Gary Carter (Born 1939) is active/lives in Montana, Arizona. Gary Carter is known for Western frontier genre and landscape painting. Born in Hutchinson, Kansas, Gary Carter is a realist painter and sculptor of the contemporary and historic American West including cowboy's, mountain men, Indians and the landscape where they live or lived. Many of his childhood trips were with his father backpacking in the Sierra Mountains of California. He served in the Army, and then earned a BFA degree with honors from the Art Center College of Design* in Los Angeles. He had moved to California with his family when his father took a job with Walt Disney productions. From 1971-1972, he was the in-house illustrator for a California design studio, but a sell-out show in 1973 of his own art persuaded him to become a full-time painter. In 1978, he won Best of Show at a Montana Historical Society exhibition. He paints the landscape and wild animals of a remote area of Montana where he lives with his wife, Marlys, near the West Entrance of Yellowstone Park. His former bunkhouse studio, where he acquired much insight into the life of the cowboy, is several miles from his home at Sun Ranch. In 1982, Gary Carter was elected to membership of the Cowboy Artists of America*, and in 1986, served as President. In CAA annual exhibitions, he received a Gold award for Drawing and Other Media in 1990 and 1997. In 1991, he was adopted by the Crow Tribe and the Real Bird Family, and, made a member of the Big Lodge Clan, given an Indian name of "Eagle Man." This adoption occurred at a Pow-Wow on the Crow reservation at Medicine Tail Coulee near Hardin, Montana, at a redesignation of the Little Horn Battlefield.
Davis Brothers Auction
Apr. 13, 2024
Gary Carter Montana Cowboy Oil Painting
Est: $3,000 - $4,000
Title is The Squaw Men. 18" by 26" unframed. 25" by 33" framed. Oil on Canvas. Gary Carter (Born 1939) is active/lives in Montana, Arizona. Gary Carter is known for Western frontier genre and landscape painting. Born in Hutchinson, Kansas, Gary Carter is a realist painter and sculptor of the contemporary and historic American West including cowboy's, mountain men, Indians and the landscape where they live or lived. Many of his childhood trips were with his father backpacking in the Sierra Mountains of California. He served in the Army, and then earned a BFA degree with honors from the Art Center College of Design* in Los Angeles. He had moved to California with his family when his father took a job with Walt Disney productions. From 1971-1972, he was the in-house illustrator for a California design studio, but a sell-out show in 1973 of his own art persuaded him to become a full-time painter. In 1978, he won Best of Show at a Montana Historical Society exhibition. He paints the landscape and wild animals of a remote area of Montana where he lives with his wife, Marlys, near the West Entrance of Yellowstone Park. His former bunkhouse studio, where he acquired much insight into the life of the cowboy, is several miles from his home at Sun Ranch. In 1982, Gary Carter was elected to membership of the Cowboy Artists of America*, and in 1986, served as President. In CAA annual exhibitions, he received a Gold award for Drawing and Other Media in 1990 and 1997. In 1991, he was adopted by the Crow Tribe and the Real Bird Family, and, made a member of the Big Lodge Clan, given an Indian name of "Eagle Man." This adoption occurred at a Pow-Wow on the Crow reservation at Medicine Tail Coulee near Hardin, Montana, at a redesignation of the Little Horn Battlefield.
Davis Brothers Auction
Apr. 01, 2024
Gary Carter Vintage MLB Baseball Cards
Est: -
Pickup on Tuesday, Apr 2, 2024 from 2:00 pm to 6:00 pm All items are sold as-is. The absence of a condition report does not imply that the lot is in perfect condition or completely free of defects, imperfections, or wear and tear. The pickup address will be released on your invoice. Invoices are sent after the entire auction has ended. Be sure to bring boxes and packing material to pickup. If you purchase a large item, be sure to bring moving help. Large items cannot be shipped. Items not picked up by the pickup deadline, NOT requiring shipping will be forfeited and you will still be charged. Items cannot be held after the pickup date. Items not paid for will be automatically charged to the card on file.
Aether Auctions
Mar. 23, 2024
Gary Carter Limited Ed. Print "Baron's Of Beef"
Est: $150 - $350
Featured in this lot is a signed, limited edition Gary Carter piece titled "Barons of Beef". Gary Carter is one of the most renowned Western & Native American artists of the past thirty years. Gary Carter is a West Yellowstone, Montana artist. He is a part of the Cowboy Artist of America and was adopted by the Crow Tribe and Real Bird Family and made a member of the Big Lodge Clan, given the Indian name of Eagle Man. The print shows ranchers and ranch hands inspecting a herd of cattle. Three men ride on a horse drawn wagon while the rest are on horseback. The print is signed in the the bottom right hand corner "Gary Carter" and numbered 407 out of 850. The print also comes with a signed Certificate of Registration & Authentication as well as an artist's commentary on the piece. Overall the print is in very good condition with no signs of damage. The art measures 19" 1/2" L x 32" W. The total print measures 23 1/2" H x 36" W.
North American Auction Company
Mar. 23, 2024
Gary Carter Limited Ed. "Aux Aliments Du Pays"
Est: $250 - $500
For your consideration is this Limited Edition Lithograph from 1986 titled "Aux Aliments Du Pays," by Gary Carter. "Aux Aliments Du Pays" is a simple statement in French meaning "Nourishment of the Land". The essence of this scene is taking what nature provides to survive a rather hostile environment that was chosen by the mountain man. In reality, it was to avoid the civilization that was brought on after Lewis and Clark had completed their exploration of the Northwest Territory. The litho is signed on the bottom right hand corner "Gary Carter" and is numbered 145 out of 850 with 85 artists proofs. Overall this print is in good condition with no signs of damage. The art measures 20" L x 31 1/2" W. The total print measures 24" L x 35 1/2" W.
North American Auction Company
Mar. 11, 2024
GARY CARTER PRINT, MOUNTAIN MAN HUNTING ELK
Est: -
GARY CARTER PRINT, MOUNTAIN MAN HUNTING ELK
O'Gallerie
Mar. 02, 2024
Gary Carter Montana Oil on Canvas Painting
Est: $2,000 - $3,000
Title is Stoop Philosopher. 18" by 24" unframed, 26 1/2" by 32 1/2" framed. Gary Carter (Born 1939) is active/lives in Montana, Arizona. Gary Carter is known for Western frontier genre and landscape painting. Born in Hutchinson, Kansas, Gary Carter is a realist painter and sculptor of the contemporary and historic American West including cowboy's, mountain men, Indians and the landscape where they live or lived. Many of his childhood trips were with his father backpacking in the Sierra Mountains of California. He served in the Army, and then earned a BFA degree with honors from the Art Center College of Design* in Los Angeles. He had moved to California with his family when his father took a job with Walt Disney productions. From 1971-1972, he was the in-house illustrator for a California design studio, but a sell-out show in 1973 of his own art persuaded him to become a full-time painter. In 1978, he won Best of Show at a Montana Historical Society exhibition. He paints the landscape and wild animals of a remote area of Montana where he lives with his wife, Marlys, near the West Entrance of Yellowstone Park. His former bunkhouse studio, where he acquired much insight into the life of the cowboy, is several miles from his home at Sun Ranch. In 1982, Gary Carter was elected to membership of the Cowboy Artists of America*, and in 1986, served as President. In CAA annual exhibitions, he received a Gold award for Drawing and Other Media in 1990 and 1997. In 1991, he was adopted by the Crow Tribe and the Real Bird Family, and, made a member of the Big Lodge Clan, given an Indian name of "Eagle Man." This adoption occurred at a Pow-Wow on the Crow reservation at Medicine Tail Coulee near Hardin, Montana, at a redesignation of the Little Horn Battlefield.
Davis Brothers Auction
Feb. 17, 2024
Gary Carter (1939- ), The Squaw Men
Est: $2,000 - $3,000
Title: The Squaw Men Dimensions: 18 x 26 1/8 Framed Dimensions: 24 7/8 x 33 x 2 Signature: signed lower right: © Gary Carter (artist cipher) 74 verso: titled, dated and signed
Jackson Hole Art Auction
Feb. 17, 2024
Gary Carter (1939-), Sneaking Drink-Givers
Est: $3,000 - $5,000
Title: Sneaking Drink-Givers Dimensions: 17 7/8 x 26 1/8 Framed Dimensions: 28 5/8 x 36 5/8 x 2 Signature: signed lower left: © Gary Carter (artist cipher) verso: signed
Jackson Hole Art Auction